MEN IN HARMONY

Perth's Premier Male BarberShop Chorus Since 1985

[ Log In ]
Skip Navigation Links
  

Technical Aspects of Barbershop Singing

 
     
 

The Detail - for those that want to know more . . . .

(sourced from the SPEQBSWA Website via AAMBS -

A technical definition from SPEBSQSA's Contest & Judging Handbook follows -

The Barbershop style

Barbershop harmony is a style of unaccompanied vocal music characterized by consonant four-part chords for every melody note in a predominantly homophonic texture. The melody is consistently sung by the lead, with the tenor harmonizing above the melody, the bass singing the lowest harmonizing notes, and the baritone completing the chord. The melody is not sung by the tenor except for an infrequent note or two to avoid awkward voice leading, in tags or codas, or when some appropriate embellishing effect can be created. Occasional brief passages may be sung by fewer than four voice parts.

Barbershop music features songs with understandable lyrics and easily singable melodies, whose tones clearly define a tonal center and imply major and minor chords and barbershop (dominant and secondary dominant) seventh chords that resolve primarily around the circle of fifths, while making frequent use of other resolutions. Barbershop music also features a balanced and symmetrical form, and a standard meter. The basic song and its harmonization are embellished by the arranger to provide appropriate support of the song's theme and to close the song effectively.

Barbershop singers adjust pitches to achieve perfectly tuned chords in just intonation while remaining true to the established tonal center. Artistic singing in the barbershop style exhibits a fullness or expansion of sound, precise intonation, a high degree of vocal skill, and a high level of unity and consistency within the ensemble. Ideally, these elements are natural, unmanufactured, and free from apparent effort.

The presentation of barbershop music uses appropriate musical and visual methods to convey the theme of the song and provide the audience with an emotionally satisfying and entertaining experience. The musical and visual delivery is from the heart, believable, and sensitive to the song and its arrangement throughout. The most stylistic presentation artistically melds together the musical and visual aspects to create and sustain the illusions suggested by the music.

(A technical definition from SPEBSQSA's Contest & Judging Handbook)

JUDGING

To give you a brief idea of how barbershop competitions are judged, the following is condensed from 80 page contest judging handbook.

We have three Judging categories: these are all judged separately by three or more Judges. There is an area where all three categories overlap, this is called the 'common ground' and is best described by the diagram below.

 

Each category is of equal importance and is awarded a 100-point band per judge per song. In a tie situation only first place is split, this is split by the chorus/quartet with the highest number of points in singing, if points are still the same then refer to the music category, then presentation.

Common Ground

Where there is the overlap in categories it allows a trained judge to talk about other areas of the performance that bothered him/her for example: If a singing judge considers that an 'over the top' presentation has affected the quality, of singing, he/she may award a lower score dependant on how much it affected him/her. This then allows the presentation judge to take the lead when the performer goes through their evaluation.

The Common Ground consists of:

  • In Barbershop style?
  • Ringing, in tune sound?
  • In good quality?
  • Suitable to the performer?
  • From the heart?

A judge's score sheet will look similar to this for each category:

 

Singing

 
  E D C- C B- B A- A
 

1

10 20 30 40 60 60 70 80 90
  Not in tune Rarely in Tune Sometimes in tune Frequently in tune Consistently in tune
  Offensive vocal quality Improper vocal quality Satisfactory vocal quality Pleasing vocal quality Excellent vocal quality
  Not a unit Rarely a unit Sometimes a unit Frequently a unit Consistently a unit
  Insignificant expansion Rare expansion Some expansion Frequent expansion Consistent expansion
  No artistry Rare artistry Some artistry Frequent artistry Consistent artistry
           

Other things the Singing category is looking/judging for:

  • In tune? - melodic #/b, harmonic #/b
  • Vocal quality? - support, free, resonant, vibrato / tremolo, bright / strident / nasal / raucous swallowed throaty, oversung.
  • Unity? - single voices, timbre match, word sound match, balance, attack and release, synchronisation, flow, pronunciation, enunciation.
  • Expansion? - degree of, quality of, R,3,5,7
  • Artistry? - musical, technical, tone colour use.

 

Presentation

 
  E D C- C B- B A- A
  1 10 20 30 40 60 60 70 80 90
  Not believable Rarely believable Sometimes believable Frequently believable Consistently believable
  No vocal expression Rare vocal expression Some vocal expression Frequent vocal expression Vocal artistry
  No visual expression Rare visual expression Some visual expression Frequent visual expression Visual artistry
  Not a unit Rarely a unit Sometimes a unit Frequently a unit Consistently a unit
  Never in command Rarely in command Somewhat in command Strongly in command Totally in command
           

Other things the Presentation category is looking/judging for:

  • Appearance - attire, focus/energy, facial/body
  • Dynamics - volume, fullness, inflection, colour, vitality
  • Motion - flow, tempo, rhythm, pace, timing, gestures
  • Comedy (if applic.) - humorous concept, believable characters, character development, action/reaction/timing, punch line(s)
 

Music

   
  E D C- C B- B A- A
  1 10 20 30 40 60 60 70 80 90
  Not consonant Rarely consonant Sometimes consonant Primarily consonant Consistently consonant
  Indiscernible theme Ambiguous theme Inconsistent theme Effective theme Continuous theme
  Inadequate embellishment Weak embellishment Adequate embellishment Tasteful embellishment Artistic embellishment
  Meaningless delivery Awkward delivery Mechanical delivery Sensitive delivery Artistic delivery
  Unskilful execution Poor execution Ordinary execution Good execution Excellent execution

Other things the Music category is looking/judging for:

  • Melody - stylistic, distinguishable, tonal centre, alteration(s) Lyrics - stylistic, quality, phrasing
  • Harmony - stylistic, barbershop sevenths, major/minor triads, voicing, progressions Range and
  • Tessitura - stylistic, good quality, balance
  • Tempo, Rhythm, Meter - stylistic, forward motion, rubato/ad-lib
  • Construction and Form - stylistic, overall concept/contour, unity and contrast, added material
  • Embellishments - stylistic, appropriateness, degree

The judges marks will be a direct reflection of your performance, if you reflect a 120 point performance they will reward 120 points. You must, however, earn those points